|
28525. iiibbb - 8/4/2006 4:57:58 PM Not that I think you're directing the comment to me WoW.
I certainly don't think my beliefs are based in fear. Does a child behave a certain way to their parent because they fear them... or because they love them.
Do most parents use carrots or sticks?
I think those that are hard on religion generalizing the motives of religious people a bit to much.
All the fire and brimstone... the threat of "eternal damnation" just seems like a human construct to me. I think they illustrate a point to anyone who might need a little humility. However, it doesn't make sense when you think about what God is about. Of course I may be absolutely wrong... but I'm certainly trying to figure it out for myself. 28526. iiibbb - 8/4/2006 4:58:06 PM One of my collegues has a rather cynical take on life... I like the irony in his thesis. People are motivated by either fear... or greed. Just about anything you offer he can twist into one of those two categories. In reality I try to be a little more hopeful than he is... but that's just greed according to him. 28527. iiibbb - 8/4/2006 5:01:54 PM My favorite part of the whole Bible is I Corinthians 13. If God loves us... if you love anything... this is what it should entail.
Words to live by. 28528. Trillium - 8/4/2006 5:31:05 PM Nice link, iiibbb.
I also like the verse on "perfect love casts out fear" (couldn't tell you where to find it, though)
Always remember though that some people actually enjoy fear, that's what horror movies are about, and they have huge audiences. If it isn't one thing it will be another. Are we going to ban horror movies as child abuse? (actually, I kind of like that idea...) 28529. PelleNilsson - 8/4/2006 6:29:10 PM 1 John 4:18 (KJV)
There is no fear in love; but perfect love casteth out fear: because fear hath torment. He that feareth is not made perfect in love.
I suppose you haven't noticed, Trillium (hello by the way!), but at the top of the right-hand column there are a number of links to internet resoures, among them the Bible Gateway, where I found the above. Your quote, in modern English is from the New American Standard Bible. The KJV is always to be preferred. 28530. TheWizardOfWhimsy - 8/4/2006 6:42:55 PM Not that I think you're directing the comment to me WoW.
I wasn't; it was just my two cents about "indoctrination" – fear & belief vs. love & faith. 28531. anomie - 8/4/2006 6:50:33 PM iiibbb,
If you think God is not to be feared, then what do you need redemption from? What's your state of being before and after redemption? 28532. iiibbb - 8/4/2006 6:59:51 PM Why should I fear God? God loves me.
When you've wronged a loved-one. Do you make ammends out of fear, or out of love and respect for them?
I don't know what my state of being is going to be. I hope it's good. I hope it's good for everyone. 28533. iiibbb - 8/4/2006 7:00:43 PM Why are my motives necessarily rooted in fear? 28534. iiibbb - 8/4/2006 7:06:57 PM In the Christian doctorine... Jesus is God's proof that he loves us no matter what.
Why does that concept necessarily root itself in fear?
This is why I identify more with Potestant doctrine. It seems more grounded in your personal relationship with God... rather than one mediated by the church. 28535. iiibbb - 8/4/2006 7:14:33 PM Message # 28532
Perhaps to make it more clear... maybe not. But perhaps the redemption is as much for me as it is for God. 28536. PelleNilsson - 8/4/2006 7:16:38 PM When you have wronged a loved one and make amends, I think it is rooted in fear: the fear of losing her love. 28537. iiibbb - 8/4/2006 7:20:16 PM Perhaps... but when you make ammends you also trust that person enough to go forward with it. 28538. iiibbb - 8/4/2006 7:20:58 PM And if God has perfect love for you... what have you got to fear if you do go forward? 28539. PelleNilsson - 8/4/2006 7:23:54 PM Nothing, except that I don't believe in the Christian (and Jewish and Muslim) God. 28540. anomie - 8/4/2006 7:27:35 PM Forgive me iiibbb, I'm really tryng to understand, but it seems I'm not being very clear. You made me believe you needed/wanted redemption from higher power, not a friend or parent. I understand forgiveness from real tangable entities. But just why do you need redemption from God if he poses no threat? If the threat is merely a withdrawel of love, how would that manifest itself? How would you know he didn't love you anymore?
What did Jesus do to "prove" God's unconditional love. If te love is unconditional, why do you need redemption? (Sorry for soundinf repetitive, but it comes from readinf your post.
How would you describe your "personal relationship" with God as anything more than and opinion about something. For instance, I can tell you some concrete demonstratable facts about anyone I have a personal relationship with. You seem to have only vague opinions and intuitions about God. And perhaps that's good enough...I'm just asking. 28541. anomie - 8/4/2006 7:30:42 PM Sorry about the typos...
iiibbb The before/after redemption question is about now, not later. I assume you recieve redemption in the here and now. If so, I wonder how that changes you. Is it just like a mood lift...a feeling of rightiousness...a fresh start - that kind of thing. 28542. iiibbb - 8/4/2006 7:31:11 PM That's fine (I am not aware whether you are an atheist or some other religion)... but your disbelief is irrelevant to my motives which I am only explaing to you. I'm not seeking anyone's validation of it. I don't need anyone's validation. Through some lenses religion appears to be pablum for a weak mind. Where someone might get themselves in trouble is judging others through their own lens.
Personally, I think there's something more to life. That's all I can tell you. 28543. iiibbb - 8/4/2006 7:46:44 PM Message # 28540 I'm just using loved-ones and parents as the direct analogy to our relationship with God as I see it.
I need redemption because I want it... not necessarily because God expects it. I just know that there is room for improvement in almost everything I am. I am completely cognizant of the fact that I don't have everything figured out.
The matter of Jesus is purely one of faith. If his role in anyone's life could be proven like a science theorum then everyone would just beleive in God and the whole idea faith would become a moot point. Faith is faith... it requires you to go beyond physical proof.
I can't justify any of my beleifs. Some of them are counter to literal readings of certain sections of the Bible. I recognize that Christianity has been heavily influenced by interpretations of interpretations. However, if I go to first principals about God being love, Jesus being a gift, and what love really means... That's when the faith starts to speak to me.
Again... I could be entirely wrong. It's just what I believe is the case as best as I can explain it.
Message # 28541
I don't know what it does for me. I suppose it will manifest itself as just peace of mind. Most of these revelations are only a couple of years old for me. I married a Jewish woman this summer and it has caused me to re-evaluate most of my upbringing and where I am in my religious beliefs.
I have no theological training. I don't claim I'm right. I don't even know why I elected to post in the first place... I ususally dread conversations about religion on the internet.
My ramblings are probably an inadequate and unsatisfying description of where I am with it all. 28544. iiibbb - 8/4/2006 7:50:59 PM Most of this is being written as I attempt to revise a manuscript... so I don't know how well I'm describing things, but I don't have time to carefully write either. I've been coming in here whenever I've had a block there.
|
